Broadcasting is the largest revenue stream for the majority of clubs in the European Big 5. With virtually no matchday revenue for the 2020/21 season, teams have relied more than ever on broadcasting revenue to keep them afloat.
The steady growth of broadcasting deals in European football appears to have reached its end, with a number of new contracts agreed recently at a reduced price to previous deals.
- New contracts have recently been agreed at reduced values in Serie A (new cycle is down 11.7% compared with the previous) and the Bundesliga (down 8.8%).
- A four-year deal agreed between France’s football league (LFP) and Mediapro until 2024 was cut short after only four months as Mediapro pulled out. After many negotiations, a temporary deal was agreed with Canal+ for the remainder of the current season. The substitute deal combined with the 1st installment already paid by Mediapro in August 2020 amounted to c. €670.0m for the 2020/21 season, a 7.8% decrease compared to 2019/20.
- The Premier League boasts the largest combined broadcasting deals amongst the Big 5 leagues at €3.6bn – 77% higher than the next highest in Spain’s La Liga. A renewal process is expected to begin soon but has been delayed seemingly due to fears the price could also be driven down in the current environment.
![Current and previous combined annual broadcasting deals, (€bn)](https://res-5.cloudinary.com/tifosy/image/upload/c_limit,f_auto,q_auto,w_1200/v1619513861/opm8aflqo89cpohok6x4.png)
Some leagues are less globally developed when it comes to broadcasting, with international rights making up a relatively small portion of the overall broadcasting revenue.
- With the now-voided Mediapro deal, France’s Ligue 1 would have had the largest percentage share from domestic revenues at 89.1% with only 10.9% coming from international deals.
- Serie A pulls in 21.3% of its broadcasting revenues from international contracts, the Bundesliga just 16.9% as these two divisions rely heavily on domestic deals.
- At the other end of the scale, the Premier League (47.2%) and La Liga (43.8%) have the highest percentage from international deals amongst the Big 5 driven by the global popularity of the top clubs.
![Domestic vs. International share of broadcasting revenues, (€bn)](https://res-3.cloudinary.com/tifosy/image/upload/c_limit,f_auto,q_auto,w_1200/v1619451738/x8dyw4mueesjlrg8ncqx.png)
All of the Big 5 leagues have adopted a collective approach to the sale of broadcasting rights, but have different ways of distributing their broadcasting revenues depending primarily on factors such as performance and viewership.
- All leagues have a fixed base of 50% equally shared amongst all clubs except for the Bundesliga, where 93% of funds are distributed according to club performances in the last five seasons (70% for Bundesliga, 23% for lower leagues).
- The Bundesliga is also the only league which distributes broadcasting revenues based upon Academy player involvement, although it only counts for 2%.
- The Premier League is the only league to provide a merit payment based on the current season, with all other leagues using previous season(s) and historical performances to drive distribution.
- The Premier League, La Liga and Serie A all distribute between 20% and 25% of revenues on the basis of viewership, either TV alone (number of televised fixtures) or TV and matchday ticket sales.
![Broadcasting revenue distribution method](https://res-1.cloudinary.com/tifosy/image/upload/c_limit,f_auto,q_auto,w_1200/v1619451842/sqnkoogxf4a0tpfzqnph.png)
On the basis of revenues received by the top and bottom club, the Premier League has by far the most equitable distribution model based on 2018/19 figures.
- The absolute difference between the top and bottom Premier League club was €46m in 2018/19 equating to a 1.6x multiple, the lowest amongst the Big 5 apart from in France where the multiple of 3.2x only equated to a difference of €41m.
- La Liga has the highest multiple between top and bottom earners at 3.8x, €167m for the top earning club and €44m for the bottom. The multiple is the same in the Bundesliga where, as the distribution methodology is 93% on performance, constant high achievers will always be guaranteed a higher pay out in comparison to lower achieving clubs.
- Serie A has the second-most equitable distribution model but the top club still received 2.9x the payout to the bottom club, with €100m compared to €35m.
![Broadcasting distribution multiple, top earning club vs. bottom, 2018/19 season](https://res-3.cloudinary.com/tifosy/image/upload/c_limit,f_auto,q_auto,w_1200/v1619514739/e5oibrboeqxjobpa9wg7.png)
Relegation and the resulting drop in broadcasting revenues in the second tier competition can be extremely challenging for clubs to manage, meaning a system is in place to grant “parachute payments” to clubs dropping out of four of the Big 5 leagues.
- Serie A and Ligue 1 work on a fixed payment methodology, with clubs receiving a pre-determined fee upon relegation.
- Although largely similar, The Premier League and La Liga distribute parachute payments based on percentage shares of overall broadcasting rights.
- The Bundesliga is the only league in the Big 5 which does not distribute parachute payments, due to their broadcasting revenues already being distributed between Bundesliga 1 and 2.
![Parachute payment distribution](https://res-1.cloudinary.com/tifosy/image/upload/c_limit,f_auto,q_auto,w_1200/v1619513593/s9somtkkgailhm49kcla.png)